Executive Selection Assessment: Know Before You Hire

Our most applauded offering. Deep insight into each finalist before a key hire or promotion.

Do not hire another executive.

Not until you know what you are getting.

A strong résumé and a great interview are not enough. The wrong executive stalls decisions, drains the team’s confidence, and leaves you answering hard questions from the board.

A wrong executive hire costs hundreds of thousands of dollars. Severance. Another search. Lost momentum. The people who leave because of the disruption. For example, a $300,000 executive who fails in 18 months would mean roughly $600,000 to $900,000 in total cost. That excludes months of lost momentum and the decisions that did not get made.

What is the Executive Selection Assessment?

The Executive Selection Assessment gives you deep insight into a leader before a key hire or promotion. You see how each finalist handles pressure, what derails them, and how well they fit the role and the culture. We use validated assessments, structured interviews, and 360 references from people who have worked with each finalist. You receive one report that compares the candidates side by side. It works for an outside hire or a promotion from within.

One decision. Ten years of leadership. A Fortune 500 CEO used it to choose one COO from three finalists. Ten years later, that executive is still in the seat. The previous COO lasted less than two years. The published case study estimates more than $5 million in repeat hiring and restructuring costs avoided. It is our most applauded offering.

What you get

  • Decision clarity: clear evidence to compare finalists before you choose.

  • Leadership risks: written findings on each finalist’s weaknesses and potential problems, before you decide.

  • Role fit: how each finalist matches the position and your culture, not just the résumé.

  • A faster start: findings that sharpen the final interviews and speed up onboarding.

Discuss your next executive hire

Frequently asked questions

What does a wrong executive hire cost? A wrong executive hire costs hundreds of thousands of dollars in severance, recruiting, lost momentum, and employee turnover. For example, a $300,000 executive who fails in 18 months would mean roughly $600,000 to $900,000 in total cost.

How does the assessment work? We use validated assessments, structured interviews, and 360 references to examine each finalist’s strengths, risks, and fit. You receive one report that compares the finalists side by side, so you decide on evidence, not instinct alone.

Can we use it for an internal promotion? Yes. It works for outside hires and internal promotions. It tells you whether a strong performer is ready for the bigger role.

How is it different from executive search? Executive search finds and recruits candidates. The assessment tells you what you are getting before the hiring decision, whether your search firm or ours found them.

What results has it delivered? A Fortune 500 CEO used it to choose one COO from three finalists. Ten years later the COO is still in the role, with more than $5 million in estimated repeat costs avoided.

Related: Executive Search, Leadership Assessment, New Leader Assimilation, and the Executive Selection case study. Back to What We Do.